Moth Mansions - Dreams turn to a Nightmare

Buying a home is supposed to be a satisfying milestone, but for one wealthy couple, their purchase quickly became a nightmare. Shortly after moving in, they discovered the property was infested with millions of moths.

This high-profile case highlights critical lessons for both buyers and sellers in the property market.

Whether dealing with pests, structural issues, or legal complications, small oversights can lead to costly disputes.

The Reality Hidden in Holes

Imagine moving only then to discover your new home is infested with millions of moths. That dream became a reality for a wealthy couple. A luxury mansion in Notting Hill had been renovated to create a perfect home but soon after moving in, the couple noticed moths crawling everywhere and investigations found the source to be larvae-infested wool insulation.

The seller of the property was a developer who had used wool insulation during the works and it turned out that Pest Control reports had mentioned the possibility of recurring problems. That information was not given to the buyers but came out at trial.

In court, the seller insisted he had acted in good faith, arguing that moths were not disclosable in answer to a question about  “vermin”. The judge decided they were and ordered that the sale be set aside and the purchase price be returned to the buyers.

Whether that will ever happen is open to doubt but fortunately in this case the buyers were wealthy enough to buy an alternative home. This case despite its out of the normal world figures - as the price we are talking about was over £30m  - highlights a number of poorly understood risks that every seller and buyer runs in the course of the process for selling or buying a home.

Hidden defects or what may be regarded as issues — whether structural, legal, or pest-related  - and what seem small issues can morph into financial and emotional nightmares.

Lesson for Sellers: If you know about a problem, disclose it.

• Withholding known information can mislead buyers and lead to claims and costs and years spent in litigation.

• Even where an issue seems minor it could remain relevant to disclose it -this  demonstrates transparency and reduces legal risks.

• Answers to questions on conveyancing forms about building works and defects and infestations, are important and should be answered honestly and completely.

• Buyers can and do find out things which reflect badly on the seller and affect other matters

• In the moth mansion case, pest control records showed the sellers had been dealing with an infestation long before the sale

• Insurance claims, planning applications and contractor records may all reveal historic problems.

• A seller who conceals known defects risks financial loss where it is a breach of contract and leads to claims for misrepresentation or even fraud.

• Covering up a problem instead of fixing it—for example, painting over damp or sealing in pests - can backfire if the issue resurfaces for the new owner.  And where a fix to a problem is attempted its best to produce all the relevant documentation.

Before Selling a Problem Property discuss the standard enquiries forms with a qualified professional adviser.

Lessons for Buyers:  Avoiding Costly Mistakes

The case of the £32 million "moth mansion" is a cautionary tale for buyers at any level. Whether you're purchasing a luxury estate or a modest home, hidden problems can turn your dream purchase into a financial and legal nightmare. Here are key lessons for every buyer.

 Never skimp on Due Diligence:

• The buyers in this case visited the property multiple times but missed signs of infestation (possibly because moths are more active at night).

• Always inspect the property more than once and at different times and in different conditions (e.g., after rain for damp issues).

• Check seller disclosures carefully and ask direct questions about pests, structural defects, prior renovations, and any known issues.

• 
  

Always Commission a Professional Survey:

• A detailed survey can reveal hidden problems. While mortgage lenders require a valuation, this does not replace a structural survey and gives no protection for the buyer.

• A professional property survey (e.g., RICS Level 3 Survey in the UK) can identify issues like damp, woodworm, insulation problems, or pests.

• If the property has undergone renovations, confirm materials used and any potential risks (as seen in this case with the contaminated wool insulation).

Investigate the Property’s History

• Past issues often resurface. Check previous reports, planning permissions, insurance claims, and renovations to spot potential red flags.

• Ask for utility bills, maintenance records, and any past structural assessments.

• Conduct online research—sometimes, past complaints, legal disputes, or issues with a property are documented in the public domain.

Reality Check for Honesty: where a seller claims an issue has been "fixed," get proof.

• In this case, the seller denied knowing about the infestation, but pest control records proved otherwise.

• Ask for guarantees, warranties, or receipts for any major work.

Be Prepared to Walk Away

• The buyers in this case spent nearly £270,000 trying to fix the problem before realising it was beyond repair.

• There will always be other homes—emotions can  override rational decision-making.

  
  

 Understand Your Legal Protections as a buyer

• Caveat emptor ("buyer beware") still applies, meaning buyers must investigate a property properly. Only, if a seller deliberately misrepresents a property’s condition can buyers sue for misrepresentation or fraud.

• Buyers should review seller responses on the TA6 Property Information Form very carefully  - asking further questions if in any doubt over the answers replies given.

  
  

  Manage your Risks and Call Us for Help - info@KMLawyers.online

  
  

  Before you Market to Sell get Help and Prepare the Material Information for Buyers